19 Reality TV Contestants Who Found Love (or Drama) Across Multiple Dating Shows – Including 17 Who’ve Been on *Married at First Sight…

Reality TV dating shows have become a global phenomenon, and some contestants are so determined to find love (or maybe just stay in the spotlight) that they’ve returned to these shows time and time again. Out of the many who appear on these shows, 19 contestants stand out for having been on more than one reality dating series, with 17 of them coming from *Married at First Sight* (*MAFS*). Here’s a look at some of the contestants who’ve tried their luck multiple times across different dating platforms.

 

### 1. **Carina Mirabile**

Carina made waves on *Married at First Sight* (MAFS) Australia before making a comeback on *MAFS* UK after her relationship with Daniel Holmes ended. Always ready for a fresh start, Carina’s persistence has made her a familiar face in reality dating circles.

 

### 2. **Sierah Swepstone**

Sierah’s stint on *MAFS* Australia didn’t last long, but her return to *MAFS* UK after her split from Adam Seed has sparked curiosity among fans eager to see if she can find true love this time.

 

### 3. **Paul Antoine**

Paul appeared on *MAFS* Australia and later found himself returning to *MAFS* UK after his relationship with Sharlene fell apart. This type of ‘second chance’ mentality is a recurring theme for many contestants across dating shows.

 

### 4. **Jeff Gobbels**

Jeff was part of *MAFS* Australia, where his relationship with Nadia didn’t work out, but he returned for *MAFS* UK in hopes of finding a more compatible partner. Like many reality stars, Jeff’s return to the dating world on TV was met with intrigue.

 

### 5. **Teejay Halkias**

Teejay’s journey started on *MAFS* Australia with Carly, but after their separation, he returned for *MAFS* UK. His quest for love didn’t stop after one failed marriage, and now fans are wondering if the third time’s the charm for him.

 

### 6. **Georges Berthonneau**

Georges first tried his hand at finding love on *Celebs Go Dating* before appearing on *MAFS* UK. His participation on these shows has earned him a place among the most recognizable faces in the dating reality TV circuit.

 

### 7. **Kieran Chapman**

Kieran started his reality dating career on *MAFS* UK before moving to other platforms like *First Dates*. His return to *MAFS* UK shows that Kieran is not one to give up on love (or fame) easily.

 

### 8. **Ross McCarthy**

Ross initially appeared on *First Dates*, where he didn’t find lasting love, but his return to *MAFS* UK proves that sometimes reality stars have multiple chances to find what they’re looking for.

 

### 9. **Erica Roberts**

Erica was matched with Jordan on *MAFS* UK, but after their breakup, she found herself back in the dating pool, trying again on *First Dates*.

 

### 10. **Theo Campbell**

Theo made his name on *Love Island* UK before later showing up on *The Challenge* and returning to *Love Island* UK in hopes of finding a second chance at love and taking another swing at reality TV.

 

### 11. **Jake Cornish**

Jake’s time on *Love Island* UK earned him a place in the hearts of viewers, but after his stint on the show, he found himself back on *The Challenge*, trying to balance love and competition.

 

### 12. **Adrienne Naylor**

Adrienne, after her *MAFS* UK appearance, joined *The Challenge*, trying to bring her reality TV experience into a new competitive environment.

 

### 13. **Izzy Fairthorne**

Izzy’s appearance on *Too Hot to Handle* was just the beginning. She later returned for *Perfect Match* and has even appeared on *The Challenge*, continually navigating her path through reality dating and competition.

 

### 14. **Rogan O’Connor**

Rogan made a splash on *Ex on the Beach* before moving on to *The Challenge*, where he continued seeking his shot at fame and fortune while vying for love.

 

### 15. **Mollie Pearce**

Mollie’s *First Dates* debut wasn’t her only reality TV appearance. She also made waves on *Dancing on Ice*, showing that sometimes a reality star’s journey extends beyond the dating scene.

 

### 16. **Sam Aston**

Sam’s reality TV appearances include *First Dates* and *Dancing on Ice*, proving that even reality TV personalities can mix romance with ice skating in the name of fame.

 

### 17. **Anton Ferdinand**

Anton’s story started on *First Dates* but later moved to *Dancing on Ice*. His unique path from romance to athleticism shows how reality TV stars continue to find new ways to stay in the public eye.

 

### 18. **Dan Edgar**

Dan joined *First Dates* in search of love, then showed off his skills on *Dancing on Ice*. Like many others, his journey proves that reality TV is a long-term career for some contestants.

 

### 19. **Michaela Strachan**

Michaela’s reality TV journey includes *First Dates* and *Dancing on Ice*. Her presence across multiple dating and competition shows shows the versatility of reality TV stars and how they navigate different genres.

 

These contestants prove that reality TV dating shows are not just a one-time experience for some; they’re a platform to try, fail, and try again. Whether for love, fame, or both, the reality TV world continues to be a space where second (and third) chances are just part of the game.